Hello,Everyone !
Here is my blog task which was given by Heenama'am about the comparison between the "Kya kehna " movie and "The scarlet letter"....
1.What are the names of the protagonists in both the works?
Ans : In the novel "The scarlet letter" the protagonist character was Hester and in "Kya Kehna "movie the protagonist character was Priya.
2.Write their story in brief.
Ans : Both movie and novel has a major and most scene was that adultery scene .both were dealing with same kind of situation and events.
About the Novel:-
It was a story of a woman by a man.we can see concept of woman.A social frame was used who has broken.There is a Hester named leading character.she was married yet she leaves alone because her husband goes away for few years.when she leaves alone she falls in love with ARTHUR DIMMESDALE and had a child,but dimmesdale don't accepted her in publically.so Hester has to suffers alot from society .she stands strongly against all problems.she cares her child alone.
About "Kya Kehna movie":-
It was also a story of woman's struggle and courageous Nature.so Priya was the protagonist of the movie.In her graduation time she falls in love with a boy named Rahul who belongs to upper class. Here we find love between middle class girl and upper class boy.They both have an affair and Priya became pregnat and rahul denied to accept this. Though Priya decided to gave birth to her child and she becomes ready to face society. After that Ajay named boy accepted Priya with whatever she was.
3.What is the role played by society in Hester’s life?
Ans :In movie society also played a role. All people raised a question on hester, her relationship and daughter pearl. They use to told with some bad name of Hester. When hester goes in market she was insulted by the people and also blown drum to told about Hester and public awared about it. Till the end people use to ask hester that who was your lover? But hester never spoke name of Dimmesdale. Yet hester hasn't fear of society she has done whatever she wants.
4.What is the role played by society in Priya’s life?
Ans : The society played a vital role in Priya's life, because when rahul refused her to accept Priya with child.she decided to gave birth to her child then it becomes very difficult to sustain against society. They were directly questions upon our identity. Their sight of looking towards us was changed. At the end of the movie,at the end of year performance she confessed whatever she has done or what she wants.
5.Compare and contrast the male characters, Roger Chillingworth, Arthur Dimmesdale, Rahul, and Ajay.
Ans : if we are talking about male characters in movie and novel then,first I would like to talk about Roger chillingworth; he was jealous man and left his wife for some years and when he comes back he comes to know about his wife's relationship with another man.now he want to take revenge of it.If we talked about Arthur dimmesdale then he loves hester by heart but he can't conffess it into public because of some reason,maybe he was afraid of society's rule but he never leaves Hester.So,he was reflected as kind and good character. Now let's talk about Rahul and Ajay.so,Rahul belong to upper class and because of status he denied Priya and he left her. whatever he has done was not good .while Ajay has a major role because he decided to accept Priya with whatever she is.
6.Compare and contrast ‘The scaffold scene in The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘a year-end performance in Kya Kehna in which a group of students performs a play on Priya and her pregnancy’.
Ans : In both scene both have to face society and have to give answer to people's questions.both are Adultery but difference was hester never take name of his lover infront of society and Priya asked all among the audience. They both accepted their child alone.
7.What are the reasons that Arthur Dimmesdale and Rahul do not come forward to accept their fatherhood? How do you they differ and what are the similarities?
Ans : I don't know much about specific reason of roger but I thought that maybe both want leave away from their responsibility.They don't want to take responsibility.
8.What is the role played by Chillingworth in Hester’s life? Why do you think he wanted to take revenge on Hester and Dimmesdale?
Ans : According to me,first chillingworth married with Hester and then he goes away from her and when he comes back he comes to know About Hester's relationship with dimmesdale and he wanted to take revenge with dimmesdale, it's was only aim of his life.
9.What is the role played by Rahul’s mother in Priya’s life? Why do you think she wants to take revenge on Priya?
Ans : In the movie Rahul's mother played a negative role.she doesn't like priya and she believes that her son hasn't did anything wrong. There is only fault of Priya so she has to pay alone .she thought my son was innocent and why he pays for it.she doesn't want to marry her son with Priya.Is it fair with priya?Is it for only that she don't like Priya? If this kind of people in our society then we never able to get justice from the society.
10.Write a note on class difference in Kya Kehna.
Ans : In movie we can see class difference between middle class and upper class.As Priya belongs to middle class and rahul belongs to upper class family.maybe Rahul denied to accept Priya because of to keep his status or standards in society.Normally the society blames on middle class.Those who belongs to upper class they don't have to much worry about it but the middle class doesn't get enough justice from society.so,class difference affects alot in anyone's life.
11.Why do you think the director has lifted the character of Ajay to the ideal state? Is it possible in real life? What are the reasons of your YES or NO?
Ans : The director has lifted the character of Ajay to the ideal state maybe because he want to make happy ending of movie,but it's not possible in real life in contemporary time it's not possible.
12.How do you see Hester and Priya as individuals?
Ans : If we say about both woman character as individuals then both are strong ,courageous and brave woman.both doesn't depend on anyone. They complete their responsibility. Here we find that Priya get support of his family members whereas Hester hasn't any kind of family.she remains alone.They don't loose their self against society's view or people.They stands and fights with it.
13. Write a critical note on the end of the movie and the novel. Why do you think the novelist has not given happy ending?
Ans : According to me , whatever happens with Hester with this Hawthorne shows that time's society,mind of that time's people.we are now forced to think about that age.
Thank you........
Here is my blog task which was given by Heenama'am about the comparison between the "Kya kehna " movie and "The scarlet letter"....
1.What are the names of the protagonists in both the works?
Ans : In the novel "The scarlet letter" the protagonist character was Hester and in "Kya Kehna "movie the protagonist character was Priya.
2.Write their story in brief.
Ans : Both movie and novel has a major and most scene was that adultery scene .both were dealing with same kind of situation and events.
About the Novel:-
It was a story of a woman by a man.we can see concept of woman.A social frame was used who has broken.There is a Hester named leading character.she was married yet she leaves alone because her husband goes away for few years.when she leaves alone she falls in love with ARTHUR DIMMESDALE and had a child,but dimmesdale don't accepted her in publically.so Hester has to suffers alot from society .she stands strongly against all problems.she cares her child alone.
About "Kya Kehna movie":-
It was also a story of woman's struggle and courageous Nature.so Priya was the protagonist of the movie.In her graduation time she falls in love with a boy named Rahul who belongs to upper class. Here we find love between middle class girl and upper class boy.They both have an affair and Priya became pregnat and rahul denied to accept this. Though Priya decided to gave birth to her child and she becomes ready to face society. After that Ajay named boy accepted Priya with whatever she was.
3.What is the role played by society in Hester’s life?
Ans :In movie society also played a role. All people raised a question on hester, her relationship and daughter pearl. They use to told with some bad name of Hester. When hester goes in market she was insulted by the people and also blown drum to told about Hester and public awared about it. Till the end people use to ask hester that who was your lover? But hester never spoke name of Dimmesdale. Yet hester hasn't fear of society she has done whatever she wants.
4.What is the role played by society in Priya’s life?
Ans : The society played a vital role in Priya's life, because when rahul refused her to accept Priya with child.she decided to gave birth to her child then it becomes very difficult to sustain against society. They were directly questions upon our identity. Their sight of looking towards us was changed. At the end of the movie,at the end of year performance she confessed whatever she has done or what she wants.
5.Compare and contrast the male characters, Roger Chillingworth, Arthur Dimmesdale, Rahul, and Ajay.
Ans : if we are talking about male characters in movie and novel then,first I would like to talk about Roger chillingworth; he was jealous man and left his wife for some years and when he comes back he comes to know about his wife's relationship with another man.now he want to take revenge of it.If we talked about Arthur dimmesdale then he loves hester by heart but he can't conffess it into public because of some reason,maybe he was afraid of society's rule but he never leaves Hester.So,he was reflected as kind and good character. Now let's talk about Rahul and Ajay.so,Rahul belong to upper class and because of status he denied Priya and he left her. whatever he has done was not good .while Ajay has a major role because he decided to accept Priya with whatever she is.
6.Compare and contrast ‘The scaffold scene in The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘a year-end performance in Kya Kehna in which a group of students performs a play on Priya and her pregnancy’.
Ans : In both scene both have to face society and have to give answer to people's questions.both are Adultery but difference was hester never take name of his lover infront of society and Priya asked all among the audience. They both accepted their child alone.
7.What are the reasons that Arthur Dimmesdale and Rahul do not come forward to accept their fatherhood? How do you they differ and what are the similarities?
Ans : I don't know much about specific reason of roger but I thought that maybe both want leave away from their responsibility.They don't want to take responsibility.
8.What is the role played by Chillingworth in Hester’s life? Why do you think he wanted to take revenge on Hester and Dimmesdale?
Ans : According to me,first chillingworth married with Hester and then he goes away from her and when he comes back he comes to know About Hester's relationship with dimmesdale and he wanted to take revenge with dimmesdale, it's was only aim of his life.
9.What is the role played by Rahul’s mother in Priya’s life? Why do you think she wants to take revenge on Priya?
Ans : In the movie Rahul's mother played a negative role.she doesn't like priya and she believes that her son hasn't did anything wrong. There is only fault of Priya so she has to pay alone .she thought my son was innocent and why he pays for it.she doesn't want to marry her son with Priya.Is it fair with priya?Is it for only that she don't like Priya? If this kind of people in our society then we never able to get justice from the society.
10.Write a note on class difference in Kya Kehna.
Ans : In movie we can see class difference between middle class and upper class.As Priya belongs to middle class and rahul belongs to upper class family.maybe Rahul denied to accept Priya because of to keep his status or standards in society.Normally the society blames on middle class.Those who belongs to upper class they don't have to much worry about it but the middle class doesn't get enough justice from society.so,class difference affects alot in anyone's life.
11.Why do you think the director has lifted the character of Ajay to the ideal state? Is it possible in real life? What are the reasons of your YES or NO?
Ans : The director has lifted the character of Ajay to the ideal state maybe because he want to make happy ending of movie,but it's not possible in real life in contemporary time it's not possible.
12.How do you see Hester and Priya as individuals?
Ans : If we say about both woman character as individuals then both are strong ,courageous and brave woman.both doesn't depend on anyone. They complete their responsibility. Here we find that Priya get support of his family members whereas Hester hasn't any kind of family.she remains alone.They don't loose their self against society's view or people.They stands and fights with it.
13. Write a critical note on the end of the movie and the novel. Why do you think the novelist has not given happy ending?
Ans : According to me , whatever happens with Hester with this Hawthorne shows that time's society,mind of that time's people.we are now forced to think about that age.
Thank you........
No comments:
Post a Comment